ToolsGroup-IHL Group 2022 Retail Inventory Study Shows Diminishing Customer Loyalty Due to Out-of-Stock Concerns

29 Sep 2022

Improving inventory position can help retailers secure consumer loyalty and capture impulse spending


BOSTON (September 29, 2022)  ToolsGroup, a global leader in AI-driven retail and supply chain planning and optimization software, in collaboration with IHL Group, a global research and advisory firm for the retail and hospitality industries, today released a study on the role of inventory in consumer loyalty and what retailers can do to win and keep customers.

In July 2022, IHL and ToolsGroup surveyed U.S. consumers on their loyalty to and trust of retailers, as well as their reasons for choosing online or in-store shopping.

The survey report: How Retailers Win Customer Loyalty in an Omnichannel World tracks the change in U.S. consumer trust in retailers over the last two years as a result of out-of-stocks. Key findings include:

  • Across sectors such as specialty apparel, mass merchants, department stores, home décor, electronics, and home improvement, the percentage of consumers decreasing trust in retailers to be in stock ranges from 28-36%.
  • However, in contrast, 32% increased their confidence in online retailer Amazon during the same period. Across other retail sectors, customers have increased their trust in inventory availability from 1-7%.
  • When shopping in-store and facing stockouts, 21% of shoppers will leave and buy from a competitor’s store.
  • As a result of ecommerce and omnichannel shopping, impulse buying has declined. This is a critical issue for retailers as up to 22% of the consumer’s total bill when shopping in physical stores comes from impulse items.
  • Retailers can counter a staggering $1.9 trillion in annual losses due to inventory distortion (the combined cost of lost sales from out-of-stocks and deep discounting) by improving their stock position.

“Our retail customer loyalty study confirmed that there is an increasing concern on the part of consumers that stores will have the items they need in stock,” said Caroline Proctor, CMO at ToolsGroup. “There is a huge opportunity for retailers to use inventory optimization to improve product availability as a differentiator, which Amazon does so well.”

→ Unlock the full consumer report: How Retailers Win Customer Loyalty in an Omnichannel World

The report offers advice to retailers for how to get customers back into the store, specifically ways to improve their stock position. These include AI-supported retail planning software such as demand forecasting, inventory optimization, real-time inventory visibility, and order fulfillment optimization to create a healthy inventory balance.

“The survey results show that, while retailers have multiple inventory distortion challenges, there are many ways they can begin to reclaim market share,” observed IHL President Greg Buzek. “Despite ongoing and protracted supply, labor, and industry disruption, the smartest retailers are doubling down on the improvements necessary to create differentiation and revenue growth.”


About ToolsGroup

ToolsGroup’s innovative AI-powered solutions enable retailers, manufacturers, and distributors to outsmart supply chain uncertainty and deliver inventory performance from source to customer doorstep to maximize revenue and profitability. Our planning suite optimizes and automates supply chains to unlock powerful business improvements in forecast accuracy, service and inventory levels, and financial KPIs, to empower a new level of intelligent, flexible decision-making. Stay in touch with ToolsGroup on LinkedIn, Twitter, YouTube, or visit www.toolsgroup.com.


About IHL

IHL Group is a global research and advisory firm specializing in technologies for the retail and hospitality industries. The company, based in Franklin, Tenn., generates timely data reports, offers advisory services and serves as the leading retail technology spokesperson for industry and vendor events. Visit www.ihlservices.com for more information.

Subscribe to the Supply Chain Planning Blog

Keep up with the latest trends, research, and insights about supply chain planning, demand forecasting and inventory optimization.